Dinosaur Jr.-Without A Sound (1994)


Artist: Dinosaur Jr.

Title: Without A Sound

Label: Sire/Reprise/Blanco y Negro

Format: CD

Cat: 9 45719-2

Year of Release: 1994

Country and Year of Edition: US 1994 Gold Stamp Promo

Sell Price: $3.70  VG+/VG+ 6/9/24

Discogs Last Sold: 4/24/24 VG+/VG+ $7.14

Low: $0.99

Median: $3.35

Average: $4.16

High: $10.99

Current low price: $3.00

Current Number on Sale at Discogs: 35

Have/Want: 2174/264

Where Sold: Brooklyn, NY

Time it took to sell:  12 years

Where and When Purchased: used Sounds NYC $8.99 sticker still on it, bought when released

Gwiz-gau Letter Grade: B-

Sad To See It Go: No

Without A Sound is a weird member of the Dinosaur Jr. catalog.  Mascis plays guitar and drums bringing in Mike Johnson for bass.  The result is a bit flatter than the previous couple albums.  That said, commercially it was his second highest charting record on Billboard debuted and peaked at #44 on an 8 week chart run (in comparison, the previous album from 1993, Where You Been, debuted and  peaked at #50 with a 15 week run, 2009's Farm debuted and peaked at #29 on a 4 week run).  Interesting how none of the first three albums that are the bands calling card had any Billboard chart success, but that was the pre-Soundscan era where independent rock records not on commercial radio didn't chart.

I've had a couple albums to write about (tomorrow will be a surprise) that were the exact same sort of thing.  One great opening hit song either that could easily be among the artists greatest hits followed by an entire record neither particularly memorable by the listener or played live by the band.  Many bands with large discographies have this type of record, but for Dinosaur Jr. one of the biggest sellers happens to be a holding pattern type.  Album number 6 of 13 studio albums and counting but really the 3rd of 4 J only Dinosaur albums of the 90's before the 2007 J-Lou-Murph reunion, each one not as good as the one before it.

The opening exception, "Feel The Pain," is rock 'n roll genius not in the middle of the road.  Despite Barlow & Murph's return they still do it live and even with harmony enthusiasm from Barlow.  I witnessed this last year on the last night of a run of shows at the Music Hall of Williamsburg playing Where You Been in full for it's 30th anniversary.  I don't think Without A Sound warrants the same treatment.  They've got bigger paydays later this year opening arenas for (ugh) Weezer.  I bet negative odds that on a shorter opening arena set they will include "Feel The Pain."

For me the only other standout song was "Get Out Of This" which is probably because of the great harmony with Thalia Zedek of Come.  As for the rest, the closing "Over Your Shoulder" was a song that made the setlist in the 90's as did "Grab It" and "Even You" from time to time.  The second track "I Don't Think So" was the only one to emerge in the modern era, one time in Glasgow in 2017 despite having a video.   

You are still going to get craggy vocals, wah (or some kind of) pedal soloing and an appropriately loud mix.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bob Dylan-Blood On The Tracks (1975)

Image
  Artist:  Bob Dylan Title: Blood On The Tracks Label: Columbia Format: SACD Cat: CH 90323 Year of Release: 1975 Country and Year of Edition: US 2003 SACD Promo sticker over barcode Sell Price: $12.20 VG+/VG+ 7/15/24 Discogs Last Sold: 7/7/24 NM/VG+ $8.99 Low: $3.00 Median: $11.63 Average: $12.38 High: $27.00 Current low price: $1.99 F/G+, $9.98 VG/VG+ Current Number on Sale at Discogs: 27 Have/Want: 334/242 Where Sold: Ypsilanti, MI Time it took to sell: 11 years Where and When Purchased: promo Gwiz-gau Letter Grade: A+ Sad To See It Go: No "I came in from the wilderness, a creature void of form..." "And when finally the bottom fell out I became withdrawn..." Bob's public precursor to his own divorce has taken a strange turn in the public narrative over the years, whether reflecting domestic tranquility or turbulence.   Beyonc é  might tell you she flips pancakes or boils an egg to Blood On The Tracks on a Sunday morning.  Jakob Dylan might rail that ...
Read more

The Byrds-Live At The Fillmore-February 1969 (2000)

Image
  Artist: The Byrds Title: Live At The Fillmore February 1969 Label: Columbia/Legacy Format: CD Cat #: CK 65910 Year of Release: 2000 Country and Year of Edition Issue: US 2000 Listed Condition VG+/VG+: hole punch in UPC Sell Date: 5/6/24 Sell Price:$3.75 Discogs Last Sold: 4/25/24 $7.87 VG/VG Low: $1.75 Median: $4.24 Average: $4.28 High: $7.87 Current low price: $2.50 Current Number on Sale at Discogs: 30 Have/Want: 524/45 Where Sold:Charlotte, NC Time it took to sell: 12 years Where and When Bought: early aughts not sure where in NYC Gwiz-gau Letter Grade: A- Sad To See It Go: No One of those releases that looks great on a shelf, but it took me 24 years after buying it to get around to paying any attention to this excellent live recording.  I guess that means I should force myself to read David Fricke's liner notes as well.  Sweetheart Of The Rodeo came out August 30, 1968 only 8 months after The Notorious Byrd Brothers and Dr. Byrds and Mr. Hyde came out a week before ...
Read more

Bob Dylan-Bob Dylan (1962)

Image
  Artist: Bob Dylan Title: Bob Dylan Label: Columbia Format: LP Cat #: PC 8579 Year of Release: 1962 Country and Year of Edition Issue: US 1970's reissue Listed Condition VG/VG+ Sell Date: 5/2/24 Sell Price:$8.93 Discogs Last Sold: 3/5/24 NM/VG+ $9.00 Low: $3.98 M/VG+ Median: $12.49 Average: $12.81 High: $24.99 M/NM Current low price: $12.00 Current Number on Sale at Discogs: 16 Have/Want: 285/176 Where Sold: Minneapolis, MN Time it took to sell: 9 years Where and When Bought: Worcester used That's Entertainment mid 80's Gwiz-gau Letter Grade: A Sad To See It Go: No "You're No Good!" the 3 year old Reverse Collector proclaimed to his mother.  "David! That's an awful thing to say!  Go to your room!"  I was just saying what was on the cover of the Bob Dylan song list on the album I had.  I was a fluent reader by age 3, as opposed to simply memorizing text my parents read to me when I was 2.  I understood the concept of "Good" and "Ba...
Read more